Stephen Colbert suffered a crisis of faith on Tuesday’s Late Show as he reported that the Vatican film critic panned the new Star Wars. L’Osservatore Romano, which is the newspaper of the Vatican “because some stories are just too complicated to report through colored smoke,” reviewed Star Wars: The Force Awakens, saying it was confused and hazy. It also had a problem with the villains, who failed to properly represent evil. Stephen, a devout Catholic and diehard Star Wars fan, said, “I’m now caught in a crisis of faith between deeply held beliefs embedded in me since childhood, and the Catholic Church.” He tries to defend the Vatican’s review, though. Watch the clip to see how.